2016 NLDS Game 4 Collapse vs Cubs
A three-run lead evaporates in a single inning as the Cubs storm back to eliminate San Diego.
The 2016 NLDS Game 4 collapse stands as one of the most painful and defining moments in San Diego Padres history. Occurring on October 9, 2016, at Petco Park, the game saw the Padres surrender a commanding lead against their divisional rivals, the Chicago Cubs, ultimately falling short of the National League Championship Series for the first time since 1998. This match is infamous not just for the loss, but for the stunning sequence of events in which Manager Andy Green's decisions and a series of critical errors dismantled what seemed to be an insurmountable advantage.
- Event
- 2016 National League Division Series - Game 4
- Date
- October 9, 2016
- Location
- Petco Park, San Diego
- Opponent
- Chicago Cubs
- Final Score
- Cubs 8, Padres 7 (in extra innings)
- Series Result
- Cubs win series 3-1
- Key Figure
- Andy Green (Manager)
Lore & Background
The aftermath was steeped in controversy regarding managerial strategy, specifically the decision to pull closer Kirby Yates for Miller and the subsequent handling of the bullpen in a high-pressure situation. This game became a cautionary tale for Padres fans, symbolizing the fragility of playoff success and the heartbreak that can follow even the most promising leads.
In Their Own Story
The air inside Petco Park was thick with humidity and hope as the eighth inning began. Fans stood, arms crossed, eyes locked on the mound where Andrew Miller prepared to face Kris Bryant. The scoreboard glowed: Padres 7, Cubs 3. It felt like a foregone conclusion. But when Rizzo's sacrifice fly landed softly in center field, sending Jayson Heyward home from third, the collective gasp was audible across the stadium. Then came the walk, then the single, and suddenly the lead was gone.
Reader's Guide
The Padres entered the bottom of the eighth inning with a commanding 7-3 lead, needing just one more out to force a Game 5. Manager Andy Green brought in Andrew Miller to face the top of the Cubs' order, a move that would later be heavily scrutinized. Kris Bryant led off with a single, followed by Anthony Rizzo hitting a sacrifice fly that scored Heyward from third, cutting the lead to one run. A walk to Jason Heyward loaded the bases, and Ben Zobrist delivered a game-tying single to center field. The momentum shifted instantly as the Cubs took an 8-7 lead with two more runs in the inning. The Padres managed to score in the top of the ninth but could not hold their ground. In extra innings, the Cubs capitalized on errors and timely hitting to win 8-7. This collapse remains etched in memory because it erased a three-run deficit in a single inning during a pivotal playoff game.
Did You Know?
- This was the first time since 1998 that the Padres were eliminated from the postseason in a division series.
- The Cubs became the first team to come back from an 0-2 deficit in a best-of-five series since the 1997 Braves, though this specific context refers to their overall resilience.
- Andrew Miller entered the game with a perfect record in his previous four playoff appearances before this outing.
- The Padres had won three of their last four games entering this match, including a sweep of the first two games against the Cubs.
More in Iconic Games & Moments
Elsewhere in the San Diego Padres universe
Spotted an error? Know more?
This is a living reference — every entry is fact-audited, and reader corrections feed straight into our audit queue. Suggest an edit · See this site's audit record